Study abroad when you're not rich
A student in Hong Kong finished the semester with $300 and posted a warning. The thread is right about what went wrong and wrong about what to do next.
Last updated: 10 September 2026
In a post titled "WARNING: Do not study abroad unless you're rich yourself or have rich parents", an American exchange student in Hong Kong described arriving with a carefully calculated budget, meeting a run of fees nobody had mentioned, and reaching the last four weeks of the semester with under $300. They were there on financial aid and scholarships, could not legally work on their visa, and watched their social life shrink to whatever was free.
Nearly 140 replies arrived. Some agreed. Many did not: a European student who came home from an exchange with more money than they left with, an American who funded three years abroad on State Department scholarships and Army Reserve pay, a Briton who pointed out that in the UK the destination sorts students by class more reliably than the passport does. The original poster later conceded the title was "dramatic flare / reddit marketing".
The failure underneath it is still worth reading closely. It happens often, it is cheap to prevent, and the lesson most readers took from the thread would keep the wrong students at home.
What actually went wrong
The money that ran out was never tuition money. In the poster's own account the extra fees came to "like half of what I came here for", and they arrived after departure, invoiced by the home institution and the host institution in turn. The budget had the big number right and no line at all for the small ones.
"Every month, I seemed to encounter a new fee either from my home institution or the institution I was studying at that I didn't know about before."
Students budget the advertised cost and get billed the actual one. Three things widen that gap.
1. A large share of the money is spent before you arrive
Immigration systems make you hold or hand over money in advance. The amounts are set by law and published openly, and they almost never appear beside tuition in a prospectus:
| Destination | Money required before you go | What it is |
|---|---|---|
| United Kingdom | £1,529/month in London, £1,171 outside, for up to 9 months | Living-cost proof, held for 28 consecutive days ending within 31 days of applying (GOV.UK) |
| United Kingdom | £776 per year of the visa, paid upfront | Immigration Health Surcharge, so £1,552 for a two-year visa, payable at application (GOV.UK) |
| Germany | €11,904 for one year | Paid into a blocked account that releases €992 a month after you arrive (Study in Germany / DAAD) |
| Canada | CAD 23,448 for one year, excluding tuition and travel | Single applicant outside Quebec, for study permit applications on or after 1 September 2026 (IRCC) |
| Australia | AUD 29,710 for one year, plus tuition and travel | Financial capacity requirement for the subclass 500 student visa (Department of Home Affairs) |
| United States | $350, non-refundable | I-901 SEVIS fee for F-1 students, paid before the visa interview and forfeited if the visa is refused (ICE) |
The first row is the one people misread. Proof of funds is money you have to hold, in an account, for a defined window, before the visa is granted. A loan that disburses after enrolment cannot satisfy it, and neither can money that appears the week before you apply. Affording the degree and passing the visa test are separate problems, and plenty of students clear the first while failing the second.
2. Your visa decides whether you can work
A commenter told the poster to pick up an online job. The poster replied that their visa made any employment illegal, and the rule backs them up.
Hong Kong lets non-local students on full-time locally accredited programmes work part-time: up to 20 hours a week on campus, without restriction between 1 June and 31 August, and since 1 November 2024 under a broader temporary exemption. Every one of those permissions carries the same parenthesis, excluding exchange students (Study in Hong Kong). A semester on exchange there comes with no legal way to earn anything, however hard you look.
Permitted term-time hours swing widely between destinations, so the number belongs in the budget:
| Destination | Avg tuition/yr | Living cost/yr | Total/yr | Term-time work |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| India | $4,500 | $4,500 | $9,000 | 10 h/wk |
| Saudi Arabia | $3,600 | $7,000 | $10,600 | 10 h/wk |
| China | $4,300 | $6,500 | $10,800 | 8 h/wk |
| Taiwan | $4,500 | $8,000 | $12,500 | 20 h/wk |
| Malaysia | $7,400 | $6,000 | $13,400 | 20 h/wk |
| South Korea | $6,400 | $8,500 | $14,900 | 20 h/wk |
| Japan | $5,400 | $10,000 | $15,400 | 28 h/wk |
| Italy | $4,800 | $11,500 | $16,300 | 20 h/wk |
| Germany | $4,200 | $13,500 | $17,700 | 20 h/wk |
| Spain | $7,000 | $11,500 | $18,500 | 30 h/wk |
| Hong Kong (the thread) | $24,400 | $15,500 | $39,900 | 20 h/wk* |
The ten lowest-total destinations in our catalogue with 20 or more course records, plus Hong Kong for comparison. *Not available to exchange students.
3. The social budget is a real budget
The part of the thread that drew the most hostility is the part we think is right. The poster described friendships thinning out as they stopped being able to join the trips and the meals, and several commenters replied that friends are free and they should have stayed on campus.
Friends are free. Getting close enough to make them usually costs something. Research on international students finds that loneliness tracks belonging, to the city, the institution and the neighbourhood, and that shared in-person activity is how belonging forms (Journal of Affective Disorders Reports, 2023). If every route into that activity in your host city carries a price, a zero social budget buys you a semester alone. Give it a line, and choose a city where the line stays small.
Where the thread is wrong
The headline tells students not to go. The evidence under it says something much narrower: do not go to that city, on that visa, with no margin. The replies pull the two apart quickly.
The destination is the variable, not your family
Across our catalogue of 1,983 course records in 29 destinations, total annual cost, tuition plus living, spans roughly a 7× range from the cheapest destination to the dearest. Hong Kong is one of the most expensive cities on earth in which to be a student. Pricing it and concluding that studying abroad is for rich people is like pricing a flat in Manhattan and concluding that housing is unaffordable everywhere.
A commenter made the same point from the other side. They came back from an exchange in Europe with more savings than they left with, because the host university charged nothing, a stipend covered rent and Erasmus+ covered food. The programme is built to work that way. Erasmus+ students are exempt from tuition, registration, examination and laboratory or library fees at the receiving institution, and the programme carries extra support for students with fewer opportunities (European Commission). That exchange runs on different arithmetic from the one in the thread.
Need-based funding exists precisely for this
Two commenters named the Gilman Scholarship, and one of them had won it. It is a US State Department programme awarding nearly 3,000 scholarships of up to $5,000 each academic year, and applicants have to be receiving a Federal Pell Grant to qualify (Gilman Scholarship Program). Low income is the eligibility criterion. The original poster applied and lost, which is a real outcome and a good argument for applying to several things at once.
But the class gap in the thread is real
One reply argued that these programmes are effectively reserved for wealthy students, and that poorer students get less institutional help once they arrive. The participation data does not contradict it. Black students made up 13.1% of US postsecondary enrolment and 4.1% of study-abroad participants; Hispanic and Latine students 20.3% against 12.3% (Center for Engaged Learning, citing NAFSA). Cost comes up repeatedly as the largest single barrier, and it bites twice: the price of the programme, and the earnings given up while on it.
We read that as an argument for better information and earlier funding applications. What sank the poster was the configuration rather than the bank balance: a high-cost city, a visa with no work rights, a budget with no buffer, and fee disclosure that arrived after the flights were booked.
Our take
If you cannot cover the destination's published proof-of-funds requirement plus two months of living costs as a buffer, do not go to that destination. Somewhere cheaper, a shorter stay, or a year later with more saved all beat arriving with exactly enough and finding out that exactly enough was never the real number.
Concretely, before you commit:
- Price the destination first. Total annual cost, tuition plus living, on one line. Compare three destinations at that number before you fall in love with one.
- Read your visa's work rule in the government's own words. Forums and agents get this wrong all the time. If the rule excludes your status, your income while abroad is zero and your plan has to survive that.
- Ask both institutions, in writing, for a full schedule of fees. Home institution and host institution, separately, and ask specifically what gets billed after arrival. That question would have changed the thread.
- Apply for funding before you apply for admission. Most scholarship rounds close on or before the application deadline, and missing them costs you a year.
- Hold a buffer you never budget against. Two months of local living costs, in a separate account, in a currency you can actually spend.
- Give the social line a number. Small, protected, and spent. It is part of what you went for.
Start from a real number
Every argument in that thread was an argument about a number nobody had worked out. Our matching quiz takes your grades, field and budget and returns courses drawn from 1,983 records across 29 destinations with the total annual cost attached to each one, tuition plus living, so you compare offers on what a year will really cost you. Every destination page carries the visa position and permitted term-time work hours next to the cost.
From there, the funding guide covers the order to attack scholarships, loans and proof of funds in; the cost guide breaks down where the money goes; and the cheapest destinations guide ranks countries on what you will really pay. You do not need rich parents to do this. You need a destination you can afford and a number you trust.
Sources
- r/studyAbroad, the thread discussed above
- GOV.UK, Student visa: money you need
- GOV.UK, Immigration health surcharge: how much you pay
- Study in Germany (DAAD), Proof of financial resources
- IRCC, Study permit: proof of financial support
- Australian Department of Home Affairs, financial capacity requirement for student visas
- US Immigration and Customs Enforcement, I-901 SEVIS fee FAQ
- Study in Hong Kong, employment rules for non-local students
- European Commission, Erasmus+: studying abroad
- Benjamin A. Gilman International Scholarship, program overview
- Center for Engaged Learning, barriers to study abroad engagement
- Journal of Affective Disorders Reports, loneliness among international students
Which of these actually fits your grades and budget?
Answer a few questions and we score every course against your marks, budget, English score and career goal, then rank them.
Find my matches →